Evidence Library

Randomized Controlled Trials

HOT-ICU

2021 Respiratory
35
2928

In patients with acute hypoxaemic respiratory failure, does a lower vs higher oxygenation target reduce mortality at 90 days?

Primary outcome: 90-day all–cause mortality – no significant difference42.9% vs 42.4% (Risk ratio 1.02, 95% C.I. 0.94-1.11, p = 0.64)

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Low oxygen target
Control
High oxygen target
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality

MENDS2

2021 Sedation and Delirium
13
422

In mechanically ventilated adults with sepsis, does the use of dexmedetomidine, compared with propofol, for continuous sedation improve the number of days alive without delirium or coma?

Trial interventions (dexmedetomidine vs propofol):Median daily dose on days administered (IQR): 0.27 mcg/kg/hr (0.11-0.61) vs 10.2 mcg/kg/min (5.5-18.4)Trial or clinical team aware of the drug used: 13% vs 15%Withdrawal from trial during hospitalisation: 5% vs …

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Dexmedetomidine
Control
Propofol
Primary Outcome
Delirium free

REALITY

2021 Cardiology Transfusion
35
668

In patients with acute myocardial infarction and anaemia is a restrictive, compared with a liberal transfusion strategy, non-inferior with respect to major adverse cardiovascular outcomes at 30 days?

Primary outcome: 30 day MACE (a composite score of major adverse cardiovascular events – all-cause death, stroke, recurrent MI, emergency revascularisation prompted by ischaemia) At day 30, MACE had occurred in 14% in liberal group …

Population
AMI
Intervention
RBCs
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
MACE at 30 days

TTM2

2021 Cardiac Arrest
61
1861

In patients who are unconscious following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, does targeted hypothermia compared with targeted normothermia, impact all-cause mortality?

No difference in all-cause mortality at 6 months Comparing HYPOTHERMIA vs NORMOTHERMIA 50% (465/925) vs 48% (446/925) RR 1.04 (95% CI 0.94-1.14, p = 0.37) HR for death in hypothermia group 1.08 (95% CI 0.95-1.23)

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
TTM at 33C
Control
Normothermia
Primary Outcome
6 month mortality
?

YOUNG

2021
?
?

In mechanically ventilated adults patients with suspected hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy does conservative oxygen therapy when compared with usual oxygen therapy decrease the risk of dying or surviving with an unfavourable …

Primary outcome: Death or survival with an unfavourable neurological outcome at 180 days – no significant difference Unfavourable neurological outcome = Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOS-E) category 1-4

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Oxygen
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Neurological Outcome

65-trial

2020 Haemodynamics
65
2463

In patients older than 65-years with vasodilatory hypotension receiving vasopressors, does a target mean arterial pressure (MAP) of 60-65mmHg compared with usual care impact mortality?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Permissive Hypotension
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality

ARREST

2020 Cardiac Arrest
1
30

In adults suffering out of hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) presenting with an initial rhythm of VF or pulseless VT, does the implementation of early ECMO facilitated resuscitation compared to standard …

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
VA ECMO
Control
Standard ALS
Primary Outcome
Survival to hospital discharge
?

Dex-CSDH

2020
?
748

In patients with chronic subdural haemorrhage, what effect does dexamethasone compared with placebo have on neurological outcome at 6 months?

Population
Traumatic Brain Injury
Intervention
Steroids
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
6 month Modified Rankin Score

ITACTIC

2020
?
411

In adult trauma patients presenting with signs of haemorrhagic shock does the utilisation of a viscoelastic haemostatic assay (VHA) augmented transfusion strategy compared to a strategy augmented by conventional coagulation …

Population
Trauma Patients
Intervention
Use of viscoelastic haemostatic assay
Control
Use of conventional coagulation tests
Primary Outcome
Alive and free from massive transfusion at 24 hours

PEPTIC

2020 Acid Suppression
?
26771

In ICU patients requiring invasive mechanical ventilation, does the use of proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) vs. histamine-2 receptor blockers (H2RBs) for stress-ulcer prophylaxis, reduce 90-day mortality?

Post-Hoc Analysis: Difference in mortality was mostly found in the group of patients with high illness severity

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
PPI
Control
Histamine-2 Receptor Blocker
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality

RECOVERY-covid-19-dexamethasone

2020 Respiratory Steroids
?
?

In hospitalised patients with SARS-CoV-2 infection does dexamethasone in additional to usual care, compared to usual care alone, reduce 28-day mortality?

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Dexamethasone
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
28 day mortality

STARRT-AKI

2020 Renal
?
2927

In critically ill patients with severe acute kidney injury, does accelerated initiation of renal replacement therapy compared to standard initiation improve 90 day survival?

Population
AKI
Intervention
RRT
Control
Standard therapy
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality
?

ANTHARTIC

2019 Cardiac Arrest
?
194

In post out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients treated with targeted temperature management, does the use of empirical antibiotics prevent early ventilator-associated pneumonia?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
IV Augmentin 48 hours
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
Rate of VAP within 7 days

CITRI-ALI

2019 Sepsis
?
170

In patients with sepsis and acute respiratory distress syndrome, can intravenous administration of vitamin C, compared to placebo, reduce organ failure scores and biomarkers of inflammation and vascular injury?

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Vitamin C
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
composite SOFA score, CRP and thrombomodulin

COACT

2019 Cardiac Arrest Cardiology
19
538

In adult patients who have sustained an out of hospital arrhythmia-associated cardiac arrest without an ST-elevation myocardial infarction, is immediate angiography superior to delayed angiography in improving 90-day survival?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Immediate angiography
Control
Delayed angiography
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality

CRASH-3

2019 Neurology Trauma
175
12737

In patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI), does the administration of tranexamic acid (TXA) under 3 hours from injury, compared with placebo, reduce…

Population
Traumatic Brain Injury
Intervention
TXA
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
28 day mortality

EPVENT2

2019 Respiratory
?
200

Does titrating positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) with the use of an esophageal balloon to estimate pleural pressure improve outcomes compared with an empirical high PEEP –FiO2 strategy in patients with …

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Transpulmonary Pressure
Control
ARDSnet protocol
Primary Outcome
Composite mortality and ventilator free days
?

HYPERION

2019 Cardiac Arrest
?
584

In patients with coma following cardiac arrest with a non-shockable rhythm, does moderate hypothermia vs. normothermia, improve neurological outcome?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
33°C compared to 37°C
Control
Normothermia
Primary Outcome
Survival with good neurology
?

ICU-ROX

2019 Respiratory
?
965

In mechanically ventilated ICU patients does a conservative use of oxygen therapy compared to usual oxygen therapy affect the number of ventilator-free-days?

Subgroups: Ischaemic hypoxic encephalopathy - better with conservative Sepsis - better with usual care Acute brain pathologies - better with usual care

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Oxygen
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Ventilator free days at day 28

PHARLAP

2019 Respiratory
?
113

Does an open lung ventilation strategy which includes maximal recruitment maneuvers (RMs) and positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) titration improve outcomes compared to traditional lung-protective ventilation in patients with moderate – …

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Open lung ventilation with recruitment maneuvres
Control
Recruitment manoeuvres not permitted
Primary Outcome
Ventilator free days at day 28
?

PreVent

2019 Airway
?
401

In adult ICU patients undergoing tracheal intubation, does bag mask ventilation (BMV) between induction and laryngoscopy reduce the risk of hypoxaemia?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Bag-mask Ventilation
Control
No ventilation between induction and laryngoscopy
Primary Outcome
Lowest oxygen saturation during intubation

ROSE

2019 Respiratory
?
1006

In patients with moderate to severe ARDS, does a strategy of early neuromuscular blockade with heavy sedation, as opposed to usual care with lighter sedation targets, result in a lower …

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Cisatracurium + deep sedation
Control
Light sedation
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality
?

SHOC-ED-3

2019 Cardiac Arrest
?
223

In patients presenting to the Emergency Department (ED) in cardiac arrest, does a standardised point-of-care ultrasound protocol, compared with usual care, affect the length of resuscitation, frequency of interventions, and …

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Point-of-care ultrasound
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Duration of resuscitation

SPICE 3

2019 Sedation and Delirium
?
4000

In ventilated, critically ill patients, does the use of dexmedetomidine as the primary sedative agent compared with usual sedative agents effect 90 day mortality?

No diff 90d mort. improved (24 vs 23 d) coma free, improved (23 vs 22d) ventilator free

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Dexmedetomidine infusion (1 - 1.5 µg/kg/hr)
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality

TARGET

2019 Nutrition
46
3914

In mechanically ventilated, critically ill patients receiving enteral nutrition does energy-dense feed (1.5kCal/ml) compared with routine feed (1kCal/ml) impact on 90 day all cause mortality?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Energy dense feed
Control
Standard feed
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality