Evidence Library

Randomized Controlled Trials

ADRENAL

2018 Sepsis
?
?

In critically ill patients with septic shock, does hydrocortisone compared with placebo, reduce 90 day mortality?

No difference in mortality but significantly reduced ICU LOS, MV days, delay to resolution of shock and blood transfusions

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Hydrocortisone 200 mg/day as a continuous infusion for 7 days
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality

AIRWAYS-2

2018 Cardiac Arrest
?
9296

In adult patients with non-traumatic out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, does a supraglottic airway device compared with tracheal intubation as the initial advanced airway management strategy, improve functional neurological outcome?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Paramedics randomised to SGA or ETT
Control
Intubation
Primary Outcome
Neurological Outcome
Ar

ANDROMEDA-SHOCK

2018 Sepsis
28
?

In adult patients with early septic shock, does peripheral perfusion-targeted resuscitation, compared to lactate level-targeted resuscitation, improve all cause mortality at 28 days?

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Capillary Refill Time
Control
Target Lactate
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

CULPRIT-SHOCK

2018 Cardiology
83
686

In patients with acute myocardial infarction complicated by cardiogenic shock and evidence of multi-vessel disease on early diagnostic angiography, does immediate multi-vessel percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) compared to culprit lesion …

Population
AMI
Intervention
Culprit-lesion only
Control
Multi-vessel
Primary Outcome
Composite mortality and renal failure
?

DAWN

2018 Neurology
?
?

In patients who are 6-24 hours post acute stroke, and have a mismatch between clinical deficit and infarct, does thrombectomy plus standard medical care, compared to standard medical care alone, …

Population
Stroke
Intervention
Mechanical Thrombectomy
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

DEFUSE-3

2018 Neurology
?
?

In patients with proximal internal carotid (ICA) or middle cerebral artery (MCA) occlusion with likely salvageable ischaemic brain tissue, does thrombectomy, at 6-16 hours post ischaemic stroke, in addition to …

Population
Stroke
Intervention
Mechanical Thrombectomy
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
90 functional outcome

EOLIA

2018 Respiratory
64
249

In patients with severe ARDS, does the early initiation of Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO), compared to standard care, improve mortality at day 60?

Population
ARDS
Intervention
VV ECMO
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
60 day mortality
?

EVALD

2018 Cardiac Arrest
?
79

In patients that survive with a good neurological outcome following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, does 48 hours vs. 24 hours of therapeutic hypothermia, improve memory, attention & executive functions at 6 …

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
TTM 48 hours
Control
TTM to 33°C for 24hrs
Primary Outcome
6 month overall cognitive impairment
?

IDEAL-ICU

2018 Renal
?
488

In patients with septic shock and severe acute kidney injury, does early vs. delayed renal replacement therapy improve 90 day mortality?

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
RRT
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality
?

Jabre

2018 Cardiac Arrest
?
2043

Is bag-mask ventilation noninferior to endotracheal intubation for initial airway management during advanced resuscitation of patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Bag-mask Ventilation
Control
Intubation
Primary Outcome
Survival with favourable neurology

PARAMEDIC2

2018 Cardiac Arrest
?
8014

In adult patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OOHCA), does the administration of epinephrine compared to placebo improve survival?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Adrenaline
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
30 day mortality

PART

2018 Cardiac Arrest
?
3004

In adults suffering out-of-hospital non-traumatic cardiac arrest, does a strategy of airway management initially with laryngeal tube (LT) compared to endotracheal intubation (ETI) improve survival at 72 hours?

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Paramedics randomised to LT or ETT
Control
Intubation
Primary Outcome
72 hour survival
?

POLAR

2018 Trauma
?
510

In patients with severe blunt traumatic brain injury (TBI) does early and sustained cooling compared with standard care improve neurological outcomes at 6 months?

Population
Traumatic Brain Injury
Intervention
Hypothermia
Control
Avoid fevers
Primary Outcome
Survival with favourable neurology
?

PRESERVE

2018 Renal
?
4000

In high-risk patients undergoing angiography, does the administration of bicarbonate and/or acetylcysteine, compared with placebo, prevent major adverse events and acute kidney injury?

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Bicarbonate
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
Composite mortality and renal failure

RELIEF

2018 Fluids
47
3000

In adult patients undergoing major elective abdominal surgery, does a restrictive fluid regimen compared with a liberal fluid regimen reduce complications and improved disability-free survival?

Population
Surgical Patients
Intervention
Restrictive fluids
Control
Liberal fluids
Primary Outcome
Survival at 1 year

Skrobik

2018 Sedation and Delirium
?
100

In delirium free critically ill adult patients receiving sedation, does the addition of nocturnal low dose dexmedetomidine prevent delirium and improve sleep?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Dexmedetomidine nocturnal intravenous infusion
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
Delirium free

SMART

2018 Fluids
?
14000

In critically ill patients does the administration of balanced crystalloids compared with saline, reduce a 30 day composite outcome of death, new renal replacement therapy or persistent renal dysfunction?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Fluids
Control
Normal Saline
Primary Outcome
Major Adverse Kidney Event at 30 days

SUP-ICU

2018 Acid Suppression
?
3298

In ICU patients at risk of gastrointestinal (GI) bleeding does the use of prophylactic proton-pump inhibitor (PPI) compared to placebo reduce mortality at 90 days?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
40mg Pantoprazole IV daily
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality
?

AMACING

2017 Renal
?
660

In high-risk patients receiving contrast medium, does prophylactic hydration with normal saline compared to no prophylaxis impact the rate of contrast-induced nephropathy?

ICU, RRTexcluded. Non-hydration non-inferior. Hydration more $$ & A/E (heart failure)

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Annane

2017 Steroids
?
?

Loading...

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

ART

2017 Respiratory
120
1013

In patients with moderate to severe acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) does use of a lung recruitment maneuver associated with positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) titration according to the best respiratory-system …

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Recruitment maneuvers + open lung ventilation
Control
ARDSnet protocol
Primary Outcome
28 day mortality

ATHOS-3

2017 Haemodynamics
?
344

In patients with refractory vasodilatory shock does the addition of angiotensin II improve blood pressure compared with standard vasopressor therapy?

Sig inc BP - ? clin sig. Not sig mort improvement (not powered mort, LOS, RRT)

Population
Shock
Intervention
Angiotensin 2
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

CHEETAH

2017 Cardiac Surgery
?
506

In patients undergoing cardiac surgery with left ventricular dysfunction, does levosimendan compared to placebo reduce mortality?

Population
Surgical Patients
Intervention
Levosimendan infusion
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
30 day mortality
?

Corl

2017 Fluids
?
124

In fluid responsive spontaneously breathing critically unwell patients undergoing resuscitation, does the collapsibility of the inferior vena cava (cIVC), as determined by point of care ultrasound (POCUS), when compared to …

Too many confounders (not RND, NICOM not std CO monitor)

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

DESIRE

2017 Sedation and Delirium
?
?

In ventilated patients with sepsis, does a sedation strategy with dexmedetomidine compared with no dexmedetomidine improve mortality and number of ventilator-free days?

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded