Evidence Library

Randomized Controlled Trials

Hernandez

2016 Respiratory
?
527

In critically ill patients who are at high risk for re-intubation, is high flow nasal oxygen non-inferior to non-invasive ventilation in reducing re-intubation and post-extubation respiratory failure?

HFNC > dec reintubation rates. No diff mortality. Frag Index 5. Baseline differences

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Nasal High Flow
Control
NIV
Primary Outcome
Re-intubation within 72 hours

HOT-ER

2016 Respiratory
?
303

In hypoxic adults presenting to the emergency department, does nasal high-flow oxygen compared to standard oxygen therapy reduce the need for advanced respiratory support?

No diff HFNP vs std O2 conversion to NIV or MV. No diff tolerance HFNP

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Nasal High Flow
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Rate of intubation
?

HYBERNATUS

2016 Neurology
?
268

In patients with convulsive status epilepticus, does the addition of therapeutic hypothermia to standard care improve neurological outcomes?

No change GOS-E < 5l; ICU or hospital mortality, LOS, seizure duration

Population
Seizures
Intervention
Hypothermia
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Neurological Outcome
?

HYPRESS

2016 Sepsis Steroids
?
380

In patients with severe sepsis does hydrocortisone compared to placebo prevent the development of septic shock?

No diff-ICU/hosp mort, LOS, MV, RRT, SOFA. Etomidate & steroid allowed pre

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

IPHIVAP

2016 Antibiotics and Infection
?
214

In adult mechanically ventilated patients, does inhaled heparin compared to inhaled saline or usual care reduce the incidence of ventilator acquired pneumonia (VAP)?

No benefit. Stopped early (futility). Poor generalisability (90% excluded)

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Heparin
Control
Normal Saline
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

IRONMAN

2016 Transfusion
?
140

In critically ill patients who are anaemic, does early administration of intravenous iron compared to placebo reduce the requirement for blood transfusion?

Inconclusive. No red PRBC. D/C Hb higher. Low proportion med pts

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Iron
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

Kacmarek

2016 Respiratory
?
200

In patients with ARDS does open-lung ventilation compared with ARDSnet ventilation improve 60 day mortality?

Open lung vent > improved oxygenation, lung mech & driving p. No diff A/E, mort

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Recruitment maneuvers
Control
ARDSnet protocol
Primary Outcome
60 day mortality
?

Marik

2016 Sepsis
?
47

Does intravenous vitamin C, hydrocortisone and thiamine in addition to standard treatment, improve mortality in ICU patients with severe sepsis or septic shock, compared with standard treatment alone?

Hyp gen only-red hosp mort, duration pressors, AKI.Improve PCT clearance

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

Morris

2016 Respiratory
?
300

In patients with acute respiratory failure, does early delivery of a standardised ICU and hospital rehabilitation programme improve physical function and reduce hospital length of stay?

No diff in hosp LOS or QoL at hosp D/C, 2 or 4m

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

NIVAS

2016 Respiratory
?
293

In patients who develop acute hypoxaemic respiratory failure after abdominal surgery, does non-invasive ventilation compared to standard oxygen therapy prevent the need for re-intubation?

6hrs/d NIV > reduced reintubation w/i 7d. (Frag index 2). No mort diff

Population
ARDS
Intervention
NIV
Control
Standard oxygen delivery
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

OPERA

2016 Respiratory
?
220

In patients who have undergone major abdominal surgery does the application of high flow nasal cannulae compared with standard oxygen therapy, decrease the incidence of hypoxemia at one hour after …

No dec hypoxia. No mortality benefit

Population
Surgical Patients
Intervention
Nasal High Flow
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Improvement in oxygenation
?

OXYGEN-ICU

2016 Respiratory
?
434

In critically ill adults, does conservative oxygen therapy compared to liberal oxygen therapy reduce mortality?

Sig mort benefit, less shock, liver failure, bacteraemia (stopped early-earthquake)

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Oxygen
Control
Standard oxygen therapy
Primary Outcome
ICU mortality
?

PATCH

2016 Haemostasis
?
190

In patients with acute intracerebral haemorrhage, associated with antiplatelet therapy, does platelet transfusion compared with standard care reduce death or dependence?

Worse neuro o/c at 3 mnths with platelet transfusion (some trial weakness)

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Platelet Transfusion
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

Patel

2016 Respiratory
?
83

In patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), does the use of non-invasive ventilation (NIV) delivered by helmet compared to NIV delivered by face mask reduce the need for intubation?

Dec intubation, ICU LOS, hosp & 90d mortality. NNT 3 (Frag index 10). Stopped early

Population
ARDS
Intervention
NIV
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

REACT 2

2016 Trauma
?
1083

Loading...

No change mort Inc rad dose. 46% control ended up with whole body scan

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

RESCUEicp

2016 Neurology
52
408

In patients with a traumatic brain injury (TBI) and refractory intracranial hypertension, does decompressive craniectomy, result in more favourable mortality and neurological outcomes at 6 months, compared with barbiturate coma …

Crani > less mortality (6&12m), more PVS & disability-37% x-over med>crani

Population
Traumatic Brain Injury
Intervention
Decompressive Craniectomy
Control
Medical therapy
Primary Outcome
Extended Glasgow Outcome Score
?

TRACHUS

2016 Airway
?
118

Is ultrasound guided percutaneous tracheostomy (PCT) a non-inferior technique compared with bronchoscopy guided PCT?

USE BOTH - US non-inferior major complications, 50% more minor Cx

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Ultrasound guided percut dilatational tracheostomy
Control
Bronchoscopy guided
Primary Outcome
Composite conversion to surgical or major complication

VANISH

2016 Sepsis
?
409

Does early vasopressin use reduce the risk of kidney failure in patients with septic shock compared with norepinephrine?

Less RRT in vasopressin group but no difference in number of renal failure free days in all four groups. Low use of steroids.

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Vasopressin (up to 0.06 U/min) + (Hydrocortisone or Placebo)
Control
Norepinephrine + (Hydrocortisone or Placebo)
Primary Outcome
Rate of AKI
?

3Sites

2015 Antibiotics and Infection
?
3471

In intensive care patients who require a central venous catheter (CVC), does the choice of insertion site affect the complication rates?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
CVC placement location
Control
No control
Primary Outcome
Composite CLABSI and DVT

ABLE

2015 Transfusion
?
2430

In critically ill patients requiring blood, does transfusion with "fresh" RBC's (stored for 8 days or less) compared with standard issue RBCs (stored 2-42 days) reduce 90 day mortality?

No diff in 90d mortality - incl subgroup analysis

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
RBCs
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
90 day mortality
?

Andriolo

2015 Airway
?
1977

Early Versus Late Tracheostomy for Critically Ill Patients - a Meta-Analysis

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Early
Control
Late
Primary Outcome
All-cause mortality
?

ANNEXA

2015 Anticoagulation
?
145

In healthy adults taking either apixaban (ANNEXA-A) or rivaroxaban (ANNEXA-R) does andexanet alfa compared to placebo normalise anticoagulation?

Adexanet > rapidly restores Xa activity, thrombin. Reduces unbound Xa inhib fraction

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

AVOID

2015 Cardiology
?
?

In patients with ST-elevation-myocardial infarction (STEMI), without hypoxia, does receiving supplemental oxygen compared with no supplemental oxygen reduce early myocardial injury?

Population
AMI
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

BLING2

2015 Antibiotics and Infection
25
432

In adult ICU patients on beta-lactam antibiotics, does continuous infusion compared to intermittent bolus increase survival?

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Continuous infusion
Control
Intermittent infusion
Primary Outcome
Alive ICU free days at 28 days
?

BRIDGE

2015 Anticoagulation
?
1813

In elective surgical patients with atrial fibrillation who are suspending their normal warfarin peri-operatively, does no bridging anticoagulation compared to bridging anticoagulation with dalteparin increase the incidence of thromboembolism or …

Placebo non-inferior. Exlcude high risk srugery, mech valves. Low CHADS2 score

Population
Surgical Patients
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded