Evidence Library

Randomized Controlled Trials

?

RENAL

2009 Renal
?
1508

In critically ill adults requiring renal replacement therapy, does higher intensity dialysis compared to lower intensity dialysis reduce mortality?

High intensity - no benefit. Risk hypophos, incr $ & workload, micronut & Abx clearance

Population
AKI
Intervention
RRT
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

SEDCOM

2009 Sedation and Delirium
?
?

Question not recorded

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Dexmedetomidine
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

TROICA

2009 Anticoagulation
?
?

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

ABC

2008 Sedation and Delirium
?
338

In mechanically ventilated and sedated patients, do Spontaneous Awakening Trials (SAT) in addition to Spontaneous Breathing Trials (SBT) reduce dependence on mechanical ventilation?

SAT + SBT > dec MV duration, ICU & hosp LOS. ?? Over sedation in control grp

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Andriulli

2008 Acid Suppression
?
?

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

ARF Trial Network

2008 Renal
?
1124

Question not recorded

Intensive > no mort benefit, more hypotension, low K & phos

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

CORTICUS

2008 Sepsis Steroids
?
499

In adult patients with severe septic shock, does hydrocortisone versus placebo reduce mortality at 28 days?

No difference in mortality. This deviates from the results of Annane 2002. Hastened reversal of shock.

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Hydrocortisone 50 mg QID for 5 days
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

ECASS III

2008 Anticoagulation
?
?

Loading...

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

FAST

2008 Haemostasis
?
?

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

POCUS: Lichtenstein

2008 Respiratory
?
260

Loading...

90% immed & accurate Dx made with POCUS - single pathology, 2 exp clinicians

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Schuster

2008 Antibiotics and Infection
?
?

#N/A

No improvement in composite outcome

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

VASST

2008 Haemodynamics Sepsis
27
778

In adult patients with septic shock, does the addition of vasopressin infusion to a norepinephrine infusion compared to a norepinephrine infusion alone decrease mortality rate at 28 days?

No benefits but was underpowered for observed mortality rate. No increase adverse effects. Low vasopressin dose, high baseline MAP suggesting no refractory shock, internal validity issues due to post-randomisation exclusion.

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Vasopressin
Control
Noradrenaline
Primary Outcome
28 day mortality
?

VISEP

2008 Nutrition
?
?

Loading...

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Insulin
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

CATS

2007 Sepsis
?
330

In patients with septic shock, is mortality affected by the use of adrenaline (epinephrine) alone in comparison to noradrenaline ± dobutamine?

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Adrenaline + placebo
Control
Noradrenaline + dobutamine
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

DECIMAL

2007 Neurology
?
38

The purpose of this clinical trial was to assess the efficacy of early decompressive craniectomy in patients with malignant MCA infarction.

Population
Stroke
Intervention
Decompressive Craniectomy
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Survival with favourable neurology
?

DESTINY

2007 Neurology
?
32

Decompressive surgery (hemicraniectomy) for life-threatening massive cerebral infarction

Population
Stroke
Intervention
Decompressive Craniectomy
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Survival with favourable neurology
?

EPO-3

2007 Transfusion
?
?

Question not recorded

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Erythropoietin
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Gold

2007 Sedation and Delirium
?
?

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

Meduri 2007

2007 Respiratory Steroids
?
91

In patients with early ARDS, does continuous methylprednisolone compared to placebo reduce lung injury scores within 7 days?

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Methylprednisolone infusion
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
Reduce lung injury scores
?

MENDS

2007 Sedation and Delirium
?
?

Loading...

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

SIC

2007 Nutrition
11
?

Question not recorded

Improved mortality in more unwell pts. Poor A/E assessment. Mult study flaws

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

FACTT

2006 Fluids
?
1000

#N/A

Cons: decreased MV, ICU LOS. No diff 60d mortality, other organ failures

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Fluids
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

Ferrer

2006 Respiratory
?
162

In patients with severe sepsis or septic shock, is the timing of first administration of antibiotics associated with the in-hospital mortality rate?

Decreased resp failure & ICU mortality. 90d mortality benefit in hypercapnia only

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
NIV
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
Re-intubation within 72 hours
?

LaSRS

2006 Steroids
?
?

#N/A

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Late rescue steroids
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Leuven II

2006 Nutrition
?
?

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Insulin
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded