Evidence Library

Randomized Controlled Trials

MOPETT

2013 Anticoagulation
1
121

In patients with moderate Pulmonary Embolism (PE), does low dose thrombolysis + anticoagulation, compared with anticoagulation alone, reduce pulmonary artery pressure at 28 months?

Safe. Reduced PASP at 28 months. Old (anatomical) definitions PHT. No mort power

Population
Pulmonary Embolism
Intervention
tPA
Control
Control
Primary Outcome
pulmonary artery pressure at 28 months
It

Morelli

2013 Sepsis
1
154

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

NUTRIREA1

2013 Nutrition
9
449

#N/A

No monitoring > nont inferior, inc vomit w/o VAP. Control > inc intolerance (def 250ml)

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

OSCAR

2013 Respiratory
27
795

Does High Frequency Oscillatory Ventilation (HFOV), compared with conventional ventilation, improve 30 day mortality in patients with ARDS?

HFOV > no 30d mort difference, improved oxygenation

Population
ARDS
Intervention
High Frequency Oscillatory Ventilation
Control
ARDSnet protocol
Primary Outcome
30 day mortality

OSCILLATE

2013 Respiratory
38
548

Does High Frequency Oscillatory Ventilation (HFOV) improve mortality in patients with new onset moderate-severe ARDS compared with standard ventilation?

HFOV > inc mort, less refractory hypoxaemia; more NMB, sedation, vasoactive drugs

Population
ARDS
Intervention
High Frequency Oscillatory Ventilation
Control
High Frequency Oscillatory Ventilation
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

PROSEVA

2013 Respiratory
?
466

Does the early application of prone positioning improve mortality in severe ARDS?

Early & prolonged prone MV > dec 28d & 90d mort.Inc card arrest supine, else no diff Cx

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Prone Ventilation
Control
Placebo
Primary Outcome
28 day mortality
Sw

REDUCE

2013 Respiratory
?
314

Is short-term (5 days) systemic glucocorticoid treatment in patients with COPD exacerbation as good as conventional (14 days) treatment in clinical outcome and does it decrease the overall exposure to …

No diff exac in next 6m, all cause mort, clin or subj o/c. No diff in steroid Cx

Population
COPD
Intervention
Steroids
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

TRACMAN

2013 Airway
70
909

In mechanically ventilated adult patients with a high risk of prolonged ventilation, does early tracheostomy compared with late tracheostomy reduce mortality at 30 days?

No benefit early over delayed (mort, MV, LOS). >50% no longer indicated after D10

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Early
Control
Late
Primary Outcome
30 day mortality

TTM

2013 Cardiac Arrest Cardiology
?
950

In adults that suffer an out-of-hospitals (OOH) cardiac arrest of presumed cardiac cause, does induced therapeutic hypothermia targeting 36°C compared to 33°C reduce mortality or reduce neurological deficit?

No diff mortality (all cause) or neuro (mRS, CPC). Not gen to long downtime

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
36°C compared to 33°C
Control
Target temp 33°C
Primary Outcome
All-cause mortality

Villanueva

2013 Transfusion
?
921

In patients who present with an upper gastrointestinal (GI) bleed, does a restrictive transfusion goal compared with a liberal transfusion goal affect mortality?

24hr endoscopy!! Reduced 45d mort & unstable rebleed in restrictive grp (Child A, B).

Population
Upper GI Bleed
Intervention
RBCs
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
He

VSE

2013 Cardiac Arrest
3
258

In patients in cardiac arrest, does vasopressin + epinephrine during CPR combined with steroid supplementation during and after CPR, improve survival to discharge with a good neurological outcome, in comparison …

Improve ROSC, survival & neuro outcome. 55% in crit care area. 25% hypoT only.

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Vasopressin + adrenaline + methylprednisolone
Control
Adrenaline
Primary Outcome
Survival with good neurology
?

6S

2012 Respiratory
?
798

In critically ill adults with severe sepsis, does 6% hydroxyethyl starch (HES) compared to Ringer's acetate reduce the incidence of death or end stage kidney failure?

HES - increased mortality (90d), RRT, blood transfusion

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Fluids
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

BEST:TRIP

2012 Neurology
?
324

Loading...

ICP guided Mx not superior to serial CTs

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Bouwes

2012 Cardiac Arrest
?
391

In patients treated with therapeutic hypothermia following cardiac arrest, can clinical examination, neuronspecific enolase (NSE), and median nerve somatosensory-evoked potentials (SEPs) predict poor outcome?

Poor outcome: clinical tests at 72hrs, NSE & SSEP N20. Multimodal to be safe

Population
Cardiac Arrest
Intervention
Clinical, NSE, SSEPs
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

CHEST

2012 Fluids
?
7000

In critically ill patients requiring fluid resuscitation, does 6% hydroxyethyl starch (6% HES) compared to 0.9% sodium chloride (Saline) reduce mortality at 90 days?

HES - increased AKI > RRT, blood products. No mortality difference.

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Fluids
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Davies

2012 Nutrition
?
181

Does early nasojejunal feeding improve the delivery of enteral nutrition in comparison to nasogastric nutrition in critically ill patients experiencing poor gastric motility?

70% target in both groups. Mild bleeding more in NJ. Prokinetics in both groups prn

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Nasojejunal nutrition
Control
Nasogastric nutrition
Primary Outcome
% of energy requirements delivered

EDEN

2012 Nutrition
44
1000

Initial trophic vs full enteral feeding in patients with acute lung injury

No diff vent-free days, 60d mort, organ-failure free days, ICU-free days, infection

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Trophic enteric feeds
Control
Full enteric feeds
Primary Outcome
Ventilator free days at day 28

IABP-SHOCK-2

2012 Cardiology
37
600

In patients with acute MI and cardiogenic shock, does intraaortic balloon counterpulsation (IABP) vs. medical therapy alone improve mortality?

No benefit. No increased complications with IABP. High x-over rate

Population
Cardiogenic Shock
Intervention
IABP
Control
Standard Care
Primary Outcome
30 day mortality
?

INTERACT2

2012 Haemodynamics
?
?

#N/A

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

MIDEX/PRODEX

2012 Sedation and Delirium
?
1001

Question not recorded

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Dexmedetomidine
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

Monnet

2012 Fluids
?
?

#N/A

Inc CI induced by passive leg riase & end expiratory oclusion pressure. PPV poor

Population
ARDS
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded

PRODEX/MIDEX

2012 Sedation and Delirium
?
1001

In adult intensive care patients requiring mechanical ventilation, is dexmedetomidine inferior to propofol or midazolam in achieving target sedation level?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Dexmedetomidine 0.2-1.4 mcg/kg/hr
Control
Propofol or Midazolam
Primary Outcome
Mechanical ventilation days

PROWESS-SHOCK

2012 Sepsis
?
1697

Loading...

No diff 28d & 90d mort., incl subgroups. More non-serious bleeding

Population
Sepsis
Intervention
Activated Protein C
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

RAMPART

2012 Neurology
?
?

Loading...

Population
Not recorded
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded
?

SLEAP

2012 Sedation and Delirium
?
?

In patients who are mechanically ventilated and sedated with opioids and / or benzodiazepines, do daily sedative interruptions reduce the duration until extubation?

Population
Adult ICU Patients
Intervention
Not recorded
Control
Not recorded
Primary Outcome
Not recorded